115 replies to this topic

[MiloIsSwift]

MH is definitely sketchy. I went to sleep last night with 6 positive and 3 negative, awoke this morning with 4 and 3. WTF? I actually gained 1% WR yesterday as well, so...who cares about ratings? I don't. I've seen where players have more positive votes than bad and it rewards them. I've also seen players with more neg than pos and still have a positive MH.

This MH crap makes zero sense. And yes it's being manipulated. You may as well be able to vote for yourself.

[Elmo_Chipshop]

stubbo66, on 30 May 2017 - 12:02 PM, said:

The biggest complaint I have is that you can't report the enemy for abuse...who cares if the reds are AFK, just makes your job easier.

 

And the other thing getting my goat are players who you rightly report for unsportsman like conduct who then see there have been reported and do it back to you.

 

The system needs to prevent retaliation if it's going to be of any use.

 

The system stinks, instead of Wargaming having a dedicated team to prevent abuse, AFK etc it's by introducing a system of self moderation. I would love to see how this pans out if certain high profile players get singled out for abuse I.e Mr Bushka for his contemptible behaviour during the 3.8 debacle.

 

[illy]

epcblue, on 30 May 2017 - 05:41 AM, said:

I've gotten 12 praises and no complaints for now, I think it might depend on your communication on battle if people get Edited agaisnt you or not. Thru certainly in my experience downvote you because you rekt their team

 

i just had 2 complaints of inactivity in a single battle just, fired 11 times and over 1000 of damage in my SU152........only 2 players did more damage......the system sucks and is totally open to abuse....another WG fail if you ask me

[AndyHe]

StripedCat97, on 29 May 2017 - 07:21 PM, said:

I have 5 complaints for being AFK while I was never AFK. This system is being abused by Edited kids. I've sent a ticket to WG.

 

edited kids? Why would people edit their child?

 

[petes85]

AndyHe, on 30 May 2017 - 05:03 PM, said:

 

edited kids? Why would people edit their child?

 

Blame WG for edited Kids 

[MrFUNtastic]

Although I really couldn't care less what my honour rating is its easy to fix. All that needs to happen is two players have to give the same vote for it to count. So you get as many votes as you like but need a 2nd. This way it would stop any malicious voting by individuals and would stop people giving inactive if the person is swearing because that's all they have left in their complaints list. Currently the voting system isn't really reflective of what's happening during the game. 

[GritG0d]

My woes seem small in comparison to others, but just found a red thumb for provocative communication! The only thing I ever type is "Left?" Etc right at the beginning.

Think this MH system needs a serious overhaul. You need names of who has posted against you and a saved copy of the game. WoT will never do that, it would take a vast resource.  Why not just keep the green thumbs, which are harmless. The red thumbs seem to be wide open for abuse.  Requiring two or more players to both vote the same would be better.

As for being "inactive", what if your connection goes down.  Nothing you can do about it.

Best way to avoid this is to play at high tiers with grown ups who know that these things happen.

Perhaps have an "I only want to play with grown ups" choice on the settings :-)

[Broadsword_]

I have to agree, the system of self moderation is open to serious abuse. I picked up 3 negative responses today for no reason.

 

You can tell the system is bust when xenodium has 8 inactive in battle responses..... ludicrous!

 

Regards

 

Broadsword

[____DILLIGAF____]

I got 5 inactive. I have never been inactive. I got them because I chose to go in a different direction to the rest of the sheep and control freaks. Dont do what they want...get an inactive. 

[jackalwolf_25052878]

MiloIsSwift, on 30 May 2017 - 12:42 PM, said:

MH is definitely sketchy. I went to sleep last night with 6 positive and 3 negative, awoke this morning with 4 and 3. WTF? I actually gained 1% WR yesterday as well, so...who cares about ratings? I don't. I've seen where players have more positive votes than bad and it rewards them. I've also seen players with more neg than pos and still have a positive MH.

This MH crap makes zero sense. And yes it's being manipulated. You may as well be able to vote for yourself.

 

​YEAH mines gone from 20-1 to 14-1  what gives with that any one know ?????? and got I my complaint from a E100 that I tracked out for my team mates to blow up 

[illy]

____DILLIGAF____, on 30 May 2017 - 07:00 PM, said:

I got 5 inactive. I have never been inactive. I got them because I chose to go in a different direction to the rest of the sheep and control freaks. Dont do what they want...get an inactive. 

 

just got another inactive for doing more damage than the rest of the team put together.........good feature WG....you're making this game better by the patch lol

[Eulengesicht_2014]

MiloIsSwift, on 30 May 2017 - 12:42 PM, said:

MH is definitely sketchy. I went to sleep last night with 6 positive and 3 negative, awoke this morning with 4 and 3. WTF? I actually gained 1% WR yesterday as well, so...who cares about ratings? I don't. I've seen where players have more positive votes than bad and it rewards them. I've also seen players with more neg than pos and still have a positive MH.

This MH crap makes zero sense. And yes it's being manipulated. You may as well be able to vote for yourself.

 

Maybe 6 positives votes from platoon service? This kind of votes disappears in a few days. Think the system works well ...

[llo1]

I must join you all, just had a series of wins today ( mainly to or second damage) and one loss (to damage by a mile) and my definite "gung ho" approach, and somewhere in this someone posted an inactive comment. 

FFS......me inactive? They must need their heads seeing to!

Against my better judgement I have submitted a ticket, WG really need to actually use their brains to launch something that is so open to abuse!

[llo1]

Eulengesicht_2014, on 30 May 2017 - 08:23 PM, said:

 

Maybe 6 positives votes from platoon service? This kind of votes disappears in a few days. Think the system works well ...

 

Eulengesicht........How the hell do you get 76627 battles and still have a life?

[Eulengesicht_2014]

illy, on 30 May 2017 - 02:58 PM, said:

 

i just had 2 complaints of inactivity in a single battle just, fired 11 times and over 1000 of damage in my SU152........only 2 players did more damage......the system sucks and is totally open to abuse....another WG fail if you ask me

 

Your actually rating is:

9/4 by a *** Rating

so what's you problem, guy? No losses by the star rating!

[Eulengesicht_2014]

Broadsword_, on 30 May 2017 - 06:59 PM, said:

I have to agree, the system of self moderation is open to serious abuse. I picked up 3 negative responses today for no reason.

 

You can tell the system is bust when xenodium has 8 inactive in battle responses..... ludicrous!

 

Regards

 

Broadsword

 

Your actually rating is:

13 against 3 negative votes by **** rating

So, what's your problem, guy! You go from *** to **** rating!

 

Xenodium actually 50 against 8 (Inactivity) by ***** general,  and you see: the system ignore the negative votes, think it's moving in the right direction ...

[Eulengesicht_2014]

____DILLIGAF____, on 30 May 2017 - 07:00 PM, said:

I got 5 inactive. I have never been inactive. I got them because I chose to go in a different direction to the rest of the sheep and control freaks. Dont do what they want...get an inactive. 

 

Actually you have 11/7 by ***** rating - more is not possible

you see the system works very well, no * losses.

[Eulengesicht_2014]

llo1, on 30 May 2017 - 08:26 PM, said:

 

Eulengesicht........How the hell do you get 76627 battles and still have a life?

 

Have you seen my start date? Think there are many people with more battles on the server ...

Edited by Eulengesicht_2014, 30 May 2017 - 08:40 PM.

[Eulengesicht_2014]

StripedCat97, on 29 May 2017 - 07:21 PM, said:

I have 5 complaints for being AFK while I was never AFK. This system is being abused by Edited kids. I've sent a ticket to WG.

 

Yes, and here are your results:

34 against 5 negative votes and a ***** rating - you become higher and higher

[llo1]

Eulengesicht_2014, on 30 May 2017 - 08:38 PM, said:

 

Have you seen my start date? Think there are many people with more battles on the server ...

 

I did notice it, 5 days after my start date!